This round up is a quick look back at this past week in TV. We pull no punches and Matthew, Mark and Omarey will give you their funny, angry, sometimes disappointed but always succinct thoughts on the shows they watch. SPOILER ALERT- Please only read things about shows you have already watched to ensure you don’t ruin your experience. Here’s a look at our thoughts about the week of 9/23 – 9/29
How I Met Your Mother
Matthew: A pretty mediocre premiere for what has become a pretty mediocre show. I did like Thomas Lennon as Klaus and Barney’s summary was pretty funny. Marshall and Lily’s running gag was like the opposite of funny and the episode generally fell flat for me as a whole.
Omarey: The 52 second story of Barney & Robin was great! Marshall and Lily’s baby delirium aquarium vision was hilarious. From Klaus’ explanation to the end was great. If they can keep up this level of quality and progress toward the mother I will be happy!
Matthew: Better than the pilot, but still plagued by some of the same issues. Like Charlie is still pretty bad, but I did like her locking Bow Guy (who will now forever be Bow Guy) to a post. Hoping the show continues to improve.
Omarey: Giancarlo Esposito is awesome. It was a cool twist that Charlie’s mom is still alive,handled very poorly. Miles is awesome enough to make dealing with Charlie somewhat bearable.
Ben and Kate
Matthew: It has been like a month since I watched the pilot, so no specific moments are standing out for me, but this felt like a solid comedy pilot. I enjoyed the running high five joke more than I should have probably.
Matthew: John Cho has quietly been great on this show. I loved the bit with him on the phone doing the fishing pole gag.
Omarey: “Dude, I defend you when you’re not here, make it easier.” “Go easy man, his wife died” The lady bunch. Jeremy Roenick and Michael Vartan cameos! Awesome.
The Mindy Project
Matthew: The first half of the episode was terrible, but it made me laugh a few times in the second half and won me over a bit. I am not sure it is my kind of comedy though.
Omarey: I liked this enough to keep watching I think. I honestly didn’t think I would be able to say that. Well done Mindy.
Omarey: CSI with cowboys in the ’60s. It was pretty solid. I really enjoyed Carrie-Ann Moss and Taylor Handley. I guess I will stick with this.
Matthew: I really liked the scene where Adam tells Amber why he has been on edge lately and that he needs her help. Zeke actually had a pretty fun plot this week as well (which in my mind seems rare).
Omarey: I am not the biggest Christina fan but seeing her breakdown was heartbreaking. Zeke revealing his test score was pretty funny. This show really handles the family dramedy well.
Matthew: The pre-challenge editing made it so obvious the blue tribe was going to lose the challenge and lose they did. Tribal was a mess. Cookies? Your tribe mates are working too hard at camp? The person you are snuggling with is like a little sister to you? What?!?
Omarey: I know a lot of it was editing but Roxy seems insane. She has a point though that couple could possibly reek havok.
Matthew: Good return for this show. Everything involving Phil’s facial hair was gold though the Cam/Mitchel storyline was kind of a miss.
Omarey: Funny episode. I liked the kidnapping of Jay, the telenovela homage and the flash forward plus Phil had some awesome facial hair. I agree with Shorty it should stay around for a bit.
Matthew: I liked it. It is definitely kind of ridiculous especially if you think about it too hard, but it was pretty intense and fun to watch. I’ll definitely be watching it going forward, but its ratings indicate it might not be long for this world. We shall see.
Omarey: It was over the top and silly at times but there were some redeeming parts to it like Scott Speedman and the scene in the cafe with the local drug lord that will be enough to keep me watching.
The Big Bang Theory
Matthew: This was a pretty lackluster premiere. I am kind of curious what they do with the Raj/Stuart thing going forward. I’m also wondering how long Howard will be in space.
Parks and Recreation
Matthew: Ben’s “bro” impression was pretty embarrassing, but kind of funny too. Also a good moment between Leslie and Ron in his office.
Omarey: Ben as a bro was amazing. I loved April’s threat at the end. Andy training to be a cop will be a lot of fun. I will also really enjoy Leslie as a councilwoman. Also, I want to attempt to drink a child size beverage in a day.
Omarey: The Quinn storyline was kinda ridiculous but shows just how much Olivia cares for people and how powerful she is. I liked this week’s case, good resolution. The president was pretty harsh on the first lady.
Person of Interest
Omarey: I loved Carter and Fusco interacting knowing about each other it was kinda funny. I love the format of this show and the flashbacks. It was neat to see Reese “talking to the machine about his friend, Finch” The wearhouse scene was great. Root is brilliant and chilling and makes for a great enemy. (Episode of the Week)
Omarey: Good episode to get this show started. I like Sherlock and Holmes and their interaction. This will be a fun show to watch.
Matthew: The doll part was hilarious. And while the part with Liz was a bit much to me, the ending with Louie in China was pretty fantastic. Very good finale.
Omarey: Louie’s Christmas with the girls was great. I liked the ending in China, strange but neat. Classic Louie.
Matthew: Great premiere. I liked getting to know this new future we are in better and am very happy we got Olivia back so soon. Her reunion with Etta was very nice as well. (Episode of the Week)
Omarey: It is so bittersweet to be watching the last 13 episodes of Fringe. I enjoyed this season premiere. It is my second favorite Fringe one behind Olivia. I will enjoy fleshing out the world of the future. Plus Markham appearance! Awesome.
Join in by leaving your thoughts on the shows you watched in the comments. Check back next week to read our thoughts from this week in TV.