Games

My Concerns about the Tomb Raider Reboot

I was one of the biggest supporters of the upcoming Tomb Raider reboot when it was announced. Heck, way back to the leak about it a year or so before it was announced, I was excited for this game. The more they showed though, the more questions I had about the direction of this new entry in one of my favorite series. My biggest worry is that the core of the franchise is being lost in here somewhere.

Not a lot of platforming has been shown outside of this opening tutorial

All the articles leading up to the official unveil had me believing that this would in fact retain what was important to the series while expanding it in an interesting new direction. I have enjoyed all of Crystal Dynamics’ Tomb Raider games to varying degrees (and the excellent spinoff Lara Croft and the Guardian of Light as well). But after three fairly similar entries, I think it was time for a change and for Crystal to put their own stamp on the series. Early write-ups described a game that retained the focus on the series’ core DNA of platforming and puzzle solving while adding more open environments within a single location, gear gating, and an experience/upgrade system. This would also start the story from scratch showing a young Lara Croft on her first big adventure.

All of this sounded like a great idea, but as gameplay was shown I became a bit more wary of this direction. The first demo I sort of gave a pass to. It was very linear and way too loaded with button prompts, but it was supposedly the first section of the game and it would open up afterwards. But well over a year later and plenty more footage shown, I have to ask: Where is the platforming? This is why I play this series. Say what you will about recent TR games, but in a world of automated platforming, these are games that make you think about where to go next in your environment and didn’t make the jumps for you. What little platforming has been shown in this game so far has looked very simplistic and not up to the series standards. My biggest sliver of hope in this regard is the leaked look at one of the hubs, but it is hard to make a whole lot out of this small bit of footage. Puzzle solving seems to be here to some extent, but that hasn’t been the focus either.

I am hoping the full game will feature less walking…

What they have shown is cool enough. Lara’s new look is great as are the graphics. Combat, the series biggest flaw recently, looks much improved. The addition of setpieces might actually be fun. Especially if they could carry challenging platforming into these situations (which I am still questioning of course). Giving it some survival aspects makes a lot of sense especially in this environment which I also like. I loved the idea of getting new gear that will allow you to get to new places. The story is harder to get a handle on. While the origin story is something that interests me, I’m not fully comfortable with the sexual assault scene or how the devs have presented it. And I am sort of hoping that despite having her friends on the island with her, we will still get plenty of that feeling of isolation while we explore tombs during the game. But this story stuff I’d rather see more of within the context of the game itself before I judge it.

I guess I just want to know if this is what the game is or if the platforming and puzzles are still going to have a big focus. They haven’t shown any of the open hub areas other than the hunting one which is supposedly a lot smaller than the others. They also haven’t shown much of the tombs which will also have a (seemingly?) big presence (there will even be optional ones). So maybe for whatever reason, they just haven’t shown the aspects I am most concerned about. The PR for this game has been kind of a mess, so maybe this just goes hand in hand with that. Or maybe they are trying to draw in a new audience by showing the footage they have, but that core Tomb Raider experience is still very much here.

… and more jumping than the current footage would have me believe

The Tomb Raider I have seen looks like a fun game though. It just looks a bit more like Uncharted than Tomb Raider. That comparison might seem backwards to some. No one is more aware of which series came first than me. But while they share thematic similarities, their gameplay focuses are wildly different and the newest TR game looks a bit more like the setpiece/narrative driven, action-oriented Uncharted series as opposed to the slow puzzle-based platformer that the Tomb Raider series is. I expect it to be an enjoyable experience regardless, but I am just hoping that core DNA that makes Tomb Raider special to me is still here in full force. And that come March of next year, I will be able to say that this newest TR is not just a great game, but a great Tomb Raider game. I’ll just have to wait and see.

Anybody have any thoughts on the upcoming Tomb Raider game? Am I freaking out over nothing? Do you share any of my concerns? Let me know in the comments. Thanks for reading!

Advertisements

9 thoughts on “My Concerns about the Tomb Raider Reboot

  1. Reblogged this on NerdyLoft and commented:
    Some really interesting points made here, I too share a concern for the new Tomb Raider game coming out soon. I understand it will be a re-imagining of the original series so some changes will be there, but if too much of the Lara Croft we all know is lost, it will be difficult to connect to this title.

    Check out the original post above, if you have any opinion on the new Tomb Raider game please do leave a comment!

  2. I completely understand where you’re coming from, Trip, but after seeing some of the videos myself; I almost feel like the platforming is going away. I can only imagine that the story board editors would see that as feasible because this is before Lara became the Lara we know – via “baby steps” in a sense.

    The game also feels very linear to me, and seems to have a lot of assisted leaps and bounds. Of course, I could be completely wrong – but wouldn’t they have shown at least SOME of Lara’s platforming abilities by now? I feel like the deadline is drawing closer and I almost feel as though that would be a huge rush to try and work on between now and then, already. I’ll keep my fingers crossed, but I wouldn’t hold my breath (unfortunately).

    • Yeah I am worried Lenny. I mean if there were all sorts of platforming going on that they haven’t shown us and all the longtime fans like me are in a tizzy, why not show us a bit. You know calm our fears. Probably because it doesn’t exist. I’m going to run off and cry somewhere now while clutching my copy of Tomb Raider Anniversary.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s